“SHE WAS TOLD SOMETHING WAS MISSING.” 🎤😮 — WHEN ELSIE RETURNED TO THE AGT STAGE, EVERYTHING CHANGED After receiving criticism during her first America’s Got Talent audition, Elsie came back to the Judges’ Callbacks determined to prove she was more than just a powerful voice. Taking on Ed Sheeran’s emotional ballad Make It Rain, she delivered a performance that immediately felt different—showing not only impressive vocals, but a level of emotion the judges said had been missing before.

by

 

Elsie Infuses Ed Sheeran’s “Make It Rain” with Southern Soul during AGT 2026 Callbacks

Elsie Gets Emotional After Singing Her Original Song, "Forgiveless" | Auditions | AGT 2026

LOS ANGELES — Powerhouse vocalist Elsie returned to the America’s Got Talent stage during the Judges’ Callbacks for Season 21 (2026) to prove her place in the upcoming Live Shows. Moving past initial critiques from her first audition regarding emotional connection, Elsie delivered an authentic, Southern soul-infused performance of Ed Sheeran’s 2014 hit “Make It Rain.”

Her raw vocal power and commanding stage presence earned her warm applause from the crowd and high praise from executive producer and judge Simon Cowell.

🎤 Transforming the Blues-Rock Classic

Written by Foy Vance and made famous by Ed Sheeran for Sons of Anarchy, “Make It Rain” offered Elsie a platform to combine deep, gospel-inspired dynamics with raw emotional grit:

[Performance Breakdown: AGT 2026 Callbacks]
  ├── Contestant: Elsie
  ├── Song: "Make It Rain" (Foy Vance / Ed Sheeran)
  ├── Arrangement Style: Southern Soul / Blues Vocal
  └── Key Moments: Stripped-back intro, soaring belt climaxes, praise from Simon Cowell

  • Vocal Execution: Elsie started the performance with a rich, low-register opening (“The sins of my father weigh down in my soul”), gradually building toward explosive vocal runs and soaring climaxes in the chorus.

  • Emotional Connection: Unlike her first audition, Elsie focused heavily on emotional delivery, allowing her authentic artistic style to lead the performance.

💬 Judges’ Feedback and Post-Performance Relief

Mississippi Mom, Elsie, Auditions with Original Song on AGT

Following the final notes, Simon Cowell commended the vocal performance with a straightforward, “Okay, Elsie. Well done.” Backstage, the judges noted a stark improvement in her ability to connect with the material:

“She just didn’t make that connection the first time for whatever reason,” the panel reflected backstage. “And this time it was like a seriously, completely different experience. The connection itself, as opposed to the vocal, was undeniable.”

Leaving the stage, Elsie expressed relief and pride in staying true to her musical roots: “I can leave here feeling accomplished because he said he wanted me to be myself, and I feel like I accomplished that. I did my best, and that’s all I could do.”