DUFF GOLDMAN THOUGHT HE HAD THE ANSWERS — BUT ONE BIZARRE HOT COCOA FLAVOUR TURNED HOLIDAY BAKING CHAMPIONSHIP INTO A BATTLE OF EMBARRASSING GUESSES, AND MOLLY YEH’S REACTION MADE IT EVEN BETTER!

HOLIDAY BAKING CHAMPIONSHIP SEASON 13 PREVIEW: JUDGES TRY TO IDENTIFY THREE FESTIVE HOT COCOA FLAVOURS

In a new preview clip shared on Instagram by Food Network, Holiday Baking Championship Season 13 host Jesse Palmer puts judges Duff Goldman, Molly Yeh, and Kardea Brown to the test with a lighthearted blind hot cocoa taste test.

1. Guessing Eggnog and Pumpkin Spice Hot Cocoa

The Truth About Dennis Van From Spring Baking Championship Season 8

Kicking off the segment, Jesse Palmer presented the panel with three festive cups of hot cocoa, challenging them to identify each mystery flavor.

The first cup, featuring a bright yellow hue, immediately sparked lively speculation:

  • Molly Yeh noted that it looked like it contained turmeric or saffron, though upon tasting it, she picked up strong notes of sugar and white chocolate—adding that she would pair it with a macadamia nut cookie or a potato chip.

  • Kardea Brown echoed the visual comparison, saying it resembled turmeric-infused golden milk.

  • Duff Goldman, however, nailed the flavor right away, declaring, “It’s nog. This is hot nog right here.” Palmer confirmed the drink was indeed eggnog, giving Duff an early lead.

TONIGHT, guest judge @mollyyeh joins @duffgoldman for the semi-finals! The  remaining four chefs create arctic-themed cakes with a frozen layer 🧊  Don't miss #UltimateBakingChampionship hosted by @jess

For the second cup, Kardea guessed it tasted like brownies, while both Duff and Molly were thrown off by the warm spices. Duff joked that if the drink were hard and crusty, he “could build a little house out of this gingerbread,” while Molly wavered between gingerbread and chai. Palmer then revealed the second drink was actually pumpkin spice hot cocoa.

2. The Final Round: Peanut Butter Caramel

Molly Yeh, Kardea Brown, Duff Goldman and Nancy Fuller are raising a glass  to desserts that raise the bar 🍷 See how they'd pair cheese and wine with  sweet treats!, An all-new #SpringBakingChampionship ...

Before the third and final round, Palmer asked the judges to take a sniff before tasting. Duff compared the aroma and flavor to caramel popcorn and Tootsie Rolls, while Molly described it as nutty and caramelly with hints of pecan.

Once Palmer revealed the final flavor as peanut butter caramel, Molly admitted she could taste the peanut butter right away. Asked about their ideal baked-good pairings, Duff opted for a cherry danish, whereas Molly suggested a cream-filled nut roll topped with crunchy, salty nuts.

3. Duff Goldman Takes Home the Festive Crown

TONIGHT, guest judge @mollyyeh joins @duffgoldman for the semi-finals! The  remaining four chefs create arctic-themed cakes with a frozen layer 🧊  Don't miss #UltimateBakingChampionship hosted by @jess

Wrapping up the challenge, Duff Goldman officially claimed victory once again, proudly celebrating with a triumphant, “I won again.” Molly playfully teased her fellow judge—quiping, “It’s getting old, Duff”—before the entire panel raised their mugs in a cheerful holiday toast.